Join the Discussion
MSNBC.com's First Read, MSNBC's Morning Joe uncritically reported Palin's misquote of Albright, ignored Albright's explanation of her remarks
Summary: MSNBC.com's First Read and MSNBC's Morning Joe uncritically reported Gov. Sarah Palin's misquote of remarks by former Secretary of State Madeleine Albright, while ignoring Albright's actual quote and her reported elaboration on her remarks.
Read more
Threaded Comments: on / off
Posted by JLyons
Posted Monday October 6, 2008 11:11:54 AM EDT / Flag this comment
Posted by pete592
Interesting that a president of a local NOW chapter introduced Palin at her campaign rally.
I wonder how the WITH'ers will spin Palin's introduction by a representative from such a "liberal" organization.
Posted Monday October 6, 2008 11:18:20 AM EDT / Flag this comment
Posted by redrhino56
Posted Monday October 6, 2008 11:41:34 AM EDT / Flag this comment
Posted by edz in reply to redrhino56
Now we know whats she reads...coffee cups...
Posted by redrhino56
Excellent post!
Posted Monday October 6, 2008 12:10:37 PM EDT / Flag this comment
Posted by mary59
Palin should be ashamed. She advocates for policies that oppress women, just the type of woman that Albright was talking against in her quote.
Posted Monday October 6, 2008 11:45:20 AM EDT / Flag this comment
Posted by Col. Harlan Sanders in reply to mary59
Exactamundo, Mary. Palin's just sort of thrashing around like an idiot now, throwing out anything that's fed to her. I don't see a big difference between "help" and "support", but that's beside the point. It's ridiculous for Palin to be even trying to push the idea that supporting her is supporting "women".
Unless she's talking about instilling a sense of personal responsibility by telling those dames to pull up their bootstraps and shell out for their own rape kits.
Posted Monday October 6, 2008 11:53:57 AM EDT / Flag this comment
Posted by mary59 in reply to Col. Harlan Sanders
I actually KNOW a woman who was beaten and raped, got pregnant as a result, and made the difficult decision to carry that child to term. It was then adopted. but I would never tell another woman that she HAD to do that.
There is more to that story, but I'll stop there. Palin and people who think like her are contemptible and shallow.
Posted Monday October 6, 2008 3:15:40 PM EDT / Flag this comment
Posted by DorisRussell
Posted Monday October 6, 2008 11:48:48 AM EDT / Flag this comment
Posted by snoopy
She's been quite busy this weekend, hasn't she? She misquoted albright, claimed Obama pals around with terrorists, and now has asked why aren't the press questioning his Rev. Wright connections. I'd like to know why the press aren't questioning her loony toons church connections, or her husbands well known connections to a terrorist organization that advocated succeeding from the US, who's founder said he hated America?
And what's the friggin' problem with McCain's staff? Geez!
McCain campaign member race baiting in Virginia
Stay classy, Bobby May:
I wonder if the McCain campaign will ask him to step down, or give him a promotion.
Posted Monday October 6, 2008 11:53:00 AM EDT / Flag this comment
Posted by fmbanker87 in reply to snoopy
perhaps you mean seceding.
Posted Monday October 6, 2008 2:29:40 PM EDT / Flag this comment
Posted by snoopy in reply to fmbanker87
why, I did spell that wrong! We need a spell checker on this site.
Posted Monday October 6, 2008 2:38:52 PM EDT / Flag this comment
Posted by Brabantio in reply to snoopy
Eye no that wood knot halve maid it any bitter.
Posted Monday October 6, 2008 2:46:00 PM EDT / Flag this comment
Posted by worrierking
So far every quote this woman uses is taken completely out of context and often is twisted around to fit her ideology.
I'm more concerned with the quote about small towns from her acceptance speech that she stole from the fascist writer, Westbrook Pegler.
The man who said "some white patriot of the Southern tier will spatter his spoonful of brains in public premises before the snow flies." about Robert Kennedy during his 1968 run for the presidency.
Posted Monday October 6, 2008 11:59:14 AM EDT / Flag this comment
Posted by Col. Harlan Sanders in reply to worrierking
Hey W-King, which quote was that?
BTW, I saw Religulous yesterday, and it includes a visit to your beloved Creationist museum. I'd never seen the life size diorama with the children playing at the edge of a pond as a T-Rex frolics nearby. The "curator" describes this display as having a "wow factor" and I can't argue with him.
Posted Monday October 6, 2008 1:14:46 PM EDT / Flag this comment
Posted by worrierking in reply to Col. Harlan Sanders
In her acceptance speech, Palin said:
"A writer observed: "We grow good people in our small towns, with honesty, sincerity, and dignity." I know just the kind of people that writer had in mind when he praised Harry Truman."
The writer she referenced was Westbrook Pegler.
The quote of his I used came from something Robert Kennedy Jr. had written for the Huffington Post.
http://www.huffingtonpost.com/robert-f-kennedy-jr/governor-palins-reading-l_b_126478.html
Posted Monday October 6, 2008 1:23:18 PM EDT / Flag this comment
Posted by Col. Harlan Sanders in reply to worrierking
Thanks, WK. I guess I could have used the Googles, but I'm in a Monday lazy ass hobo sort of mood, so I took the Barney route to knowledge. Ask others to do the work!
Posted Monday October 6, 2008 2:05:47 PM EDT / Flag this comment
Posted by worrierking in reply to Col. Harlan Sanders
Thanks Colonel. I had a link to that picture and can't seem to find it now. It's one of my favorite pictures of the last few years.
I've been taking my kids, and now my grandkids to the Natural History Museum at Yale since they were toddlers. I know they'd have a ball at the Creation Museum, but only because they, like their grandfather have a very twisted sense of humor.
We'd probably be thrown out for laughing so much.
Posted Monday October 6, 2008 2:17:14 PM EDT / Flag this comment
Posted by Col. Harlan Sanders in reply to worrierking
WK, here's a good site with a photo-essay, and maybe where the photo came from originally. .Check the comments as you roll over each photo.
Posted Monday October 6, 2008 2:26:29 PM EDT / Flag this comment
Posted by mk3872
AMAZZZZZING! They looked right past her misrepresentation of Albright, who sent out a scathing retort to Palin and noted her misquote yesterday. Instead, the MSM just focuses on style, superfulousness and tactic. Glossed right on by the mistake and the insinuation that you either vote for Palin if you are a woman or you will go to hell. Real nice.
Posted Monday October 6, 2008 12:10:03 PM EDT / Flag this comment
Posted by eweston8542983 in reply to mk3872
Well sounds like we'll be in good company.
Posted Monday October 6, 2008 12:12:48 PM EDT / Flag this comment
Posted by jim.mccormack6428 in reply to mk3872
For the record, Ms. Albright made the comment "there is a place in hell for women who do not help/support other women" while speaking to a group of women parliamentarians during a visit to Hungary. And, interestingly, earlier this year, when Hillary Clinton supporters embraced the comment during Hillary's battle with Barack Obama, Ms. Albright had no opposition to its use in a political setting.
Posted Tuesday October 7, 2008 5:13:47 PM EDT / Flag this comment
Posted by Brabantio in reply to jim.mccormack6428
Was Albright talking about women getting elected, or was she talking about women's issues? It makes a profound difference.
Posted Wednesday October 8, 2008 11:16:46 AM EDT / Flag this comment
Posted by jim.mccormack6428
Merrian-Webster online first definition of "help": to give assistance or support ...
Posted Monday October 6, 2008 12:17:10 PM EDT / Flag this comment
Posted by Craig in reply to jim.mccormack6428
"Albright said her remarks 'had nothing to do with politics.'"
Posted Monday October 6, 2008 12:47:05 PM EDT / Flag this comment
Posted by jim.mccormack6428 in reply to Craig
Really? Madeline Albright originally made the statement during a visit to Hungary. She was speaking to a group of Hungarian women parliamentarians. And, in March of this year, when Hillary Clinton was vying with Barrack Obama for the Democratic nomination, an online Hillary Clinton forum, which drew nearly a half-million hits, loved Ms. Albright's comment. "There is a special place in hell for women who do not support/help other women" ranked 38th among the hundreds of slogans suggested by Hillary supporters.
Posted Tuesday October 7, 2008 5:05:38 PM EDT / Flag this comment
Posted by jim.mccormack6428 in reply to Craig
I think, in a post a moment ago, I misspelled Barak. I apologize.
Posted Tuesday October 7, 2008 5:15:04 PM EDT / Flag this comment
Posted by snoopy
Posted Monday October 6, 2008 12:17:37 PM EDT / Flag this comment
Posted by magnolialover
Posted Monday October 6, 2008 12:25:35 PM EDT / Flag this comment
Posted by robotchubby
Posted Monday October 6, 2008 12:39:29 PM EDT / Flag this comment
Posted by magnolialover in reply to robotchubby
Exactly. They have NO evidence that he's getting foreign donations, but he must be, because Newsmax said so? Man, that's pretty freakin' funny using them as a source of anything aside from say, a fish wrapper.
Posted Monday October 6, 2008 6:09:28 PM EDT / Flag this comment
Posted by shaggles
Posted Monday October 6, 2008 12:58:24 PM EDT / Flag this comment
Posted by Brabantio in reply to shaggles
Exactly, the Obama camp should run an ad about her position on rape kits and abortion and end it with her saying that quote. That would be brutal.
Posted Monday October 6, 2008 1:06:01 PM EDT / Flag this comment
Posted by nerzog
The role of the Palindrone Twit is clear now. They'll use her as a talking points parrot, and try to draw the Obama campaign into the gutter, since the real issues are 100% against the Grampy/Twit ticket. They'll bounce her around the country, speaking in safe, Troglodyte districts where the crowds will drool in approval. She will avoid the press as much as possible, and if the Obama campaign responds in kind, they'll be accused of "sexism".
Pretty good plan, I guess, when it's all you've got.
Posted Monday October 6, 2008 1:57:50 PM EDT / Flag this comment
Posted by Col. Harlan Sanders in reply to nerzog
Nerz, I saw some footage this morning of Palin speaking in Fla. (Clearwater?), and it must have been to the hardcore base, because it made the talking points she was spouting last week ( when she was supposed to be participating in a debate) sound relatively brilliant.
There are crowds of wingnuts going to see her, and cheering enthusiastically, but they really have to be the fringe. Even mildly wingnutty Repubs have to be embarrassed by this imbecile.
Posted Monday October 6, 2008 2:16:59 PM EDT / Flag this comment
Posted by worrierking in reply to Col. Harlan Sanders
I read about her appearance in clearwater and found this information. Here's the link.
Reporters weren't permitted to wander around inside Coachman Park in Clearwater to talk to Palin's audience, the St. Petersburg Times reported.
"When reporters tried to leave the designated press area and head to where the crowd was seated, an escort would dart out, confront him or her and say, "Can I help you?" and turn the person around, Times staff writer Eileen Schulte wrote on the paper's Web site. When one reporter asked an escort, who would not give her name, why the press wasn't allowed to mingle, she said that in the past, negative things had been written, Schulte reported."
So much for freedom of the press.
Posted Monday October 6, 2008 2:21:55 PM EDT / Flag this comment
Posted by magnolialover in reply to worrierking
And another reason as to how McCain's campaign now starts to look more and more Bush-like. I'm sure that signed pledges are next before they'll let anyone into a Palin campaign event, or I'm sure that they're screening out people who might disagree with her already.
Posted Monday October 6, 2008 6:11:08 PM EDT / Flag this comment
Posted by pete592
Big surprise. No takers in the WITH Patrol so far. Figures.
Posted Monday October 6, 2008 2:48:59 PM EDT / Flag this comment
Posted by donaldmaddog5642
I regret my description of Sarah Palin as an idiot, an air-head, a moron, a homophobe, a trash-talkin', uniformed fool. She is the PERFECT VP pick for John McCain. PERFECT. Although I am certain that it was not McCain, personally, that made the choice. He is incapable of making choices. It is not that Palin IS all the things I mentioned above, but that she will appeal to all of the idiotic, air-headed, homophobic,trash-talkin', uninformed fools who form the GOP base. In MY humble opinion, Sarah MAY be all those things. Somehow I can't really believe that anyone COULD be all those things. My suspicions tell me that she is "doing" a Tina Fey. Most politicians are good actors and present themselves as something they are not. That's a given. Any smart ad person knows, in order to "sell" a product, you need a spokesperson, someone who will give your product a "face" who will target a demographic. Get it?
Posted Monday October 6, 2008 4:35:42 PM EDT / Flag this comment
Posted by wesley
Will somebody invite Foser to the mmfa staff meetings...or if he is invited...please listen to him once in a while.
-- With little more than a month to go before Election Day, voters need the news media to cut through the clutter of the candidates' competing sound bites and spin. They need clear and concise explanations of what, exactly, the candidates would do if elected. And they need the media to provide this every day, not just once in a while.
Unfortunately, they aren't getting it. Instead, they are faced with countless news reports that simply repeat charges and counter-charges or obsess over minor details while failing to provide the big picture - news reports that obscure rather than clarify the candidates' proposals and positions. -- Foser
mmfa has just set a new standard for WITH reporting...I guess they're trying to act like the big media folks. They pick nits over the words help or support.
mmfa cited no source or context for Albright's comments. mmfa cites Conroy, who provides no sourcing or context for Albright's comments. Pitney? He just reports that Conroy said it. If I've missed it...please don't hesitate to correct me.
In the meantime...will someone...hell, anybody...at mmfa listen to Foser. He gets it.
Posted Monday October 6, 2008 5:29:50 PM EDT / Flag this comment
Posted by magnolialover in reply to wesley
Umm. You do realize that MMFA is reporting ON the reporting. They don't actually report on the news. I'm just saying. It's called being a media watchdog. They don't write the news, they just report ON the news.
Posted Monday October 6, 2008 6:12:15 PM EDT / Flag this comment
Posted by wesley in reply to magnolialover
Umm...what I realize is that mmfa is complicit in the same shoddy reporting identified by Foser. You and mmfa may want to hide behind the excuse of reporting ON the news...but it doesn't wash. This type of article by mma adds nothing to the story...means nothing to anyone seeking information...it's simply partisan red meat to the legions.
It's exactly as Foser stated so well...just obsessing over minor details. Remember that the next time mmfa piously talks about a certain media reporting a story one way while ignoring a contradictory report from the same media...as well as mmfa ignoring Foser's sound advice.
Posted Monday October 6, 2008 9:46:09 PM EDT / Flag this comment
Posted by Brabantio in reply to wesley
In Albright's context, "help women" means exactly that, to help women. In a political context, "support women" means to vote for them. Albright's quote did not suggest that one bit.
In your next breath, you want to know the context for Albright's comments. Why? If context means anything, then it's not "picking nits" to point out the difference between "help" and "support" in differing contexts. If Albright was talking about women running for office when she made the comment, then you have a point.
Albright made her own comment. Believe it or don't, but it doesn't look like Palin has any basis for her interpretation, and the media should point that out.
Posted Monday October 6, 2008 6:39:51 PM EDT / Flag this comment
Posted by Brabantio in reply to Brabantio
I should say "As it stands on its own, 'help women' means exactly that". That's absent of a specific context.
Posted Monday October 6, 2008 7:17:18 PM EDT / Flag this comment
Posted by jerrycDenver
Posted Monday October 6, 2008 5:52:16 PM EDT / Flag this comment