Join the Discussion
USA Today uncritically reported McCain's reference to Obama as National Journal's "most liberal senator"
Summary: USA Today uncritically reported that Sen. John McCain "noted" that Sen. Barack Obama "was once named the most liberal senator by National Journal magazine." But USA Today did not report that McCain himself "did not vote frequently enough" to receive a rating. Further, USA Today did not report that the National Journal ranking was based on 99 votes selected by the magazine's staff, a subjective methodology that Obama himself has criticized.
Read more
Threaded Comments: on / off
Posted by anotheramerican
Posted Friday June 6, 2008 4:30:06 PM EDT / Flag this comment
Posted by wzwriter in reply to anotheramerican
Posted Friday June 6, 2008 4:32:35 PM EDT / Flag this comment
Posted by anotheramerican in reply to wzwriter
wz,
A fair criticism of McCain.
Posted Friday June 6, 2008 4:33:38 PM EDT / Flag this comment
Posted by friedbergboy1422 in reply to anotheramerican
AA,
No, he's not. Even the American Conservative Union doesn't think so.
Posted Friday June 6, 2008 4:54:00 PM EDT / Flag this comment
Posted by wzwriter
Posted Friday June 6, 2008 4:30:38 PM EDT / Flag this comment
Posted by juliajayne
"among the 99 votes Obama cast that contributed to National Journal's "most liberal senator" label -- in addition to the ethics office vote he named -- were those to implement the 9-11 Commission's homeland security recommendations, provide more children with health insurance, expand federal funding for embryonic stem-cell research, and maintain a federal minimum wage"
That liberal Bastid! Wanting things the majority of Americans support.
Posted Friday June 6, 2008 4:30:50 PM EDT / Flag this comment
Posted by anotheramerican in reply to juliajayne
Julia,
There ya go basing liberals again by calling Obama a name. tsk. tsk.
Posted Friday June 6, 2008 4:36:08 PM EDT / Flag this comment
Posted by anotheramerican in reply to anotheramerican
Posted Friday June 6, 2008 4:36:29 PM EDT / Flag this comment
Posted by Dem02020 in reply to juliajayne
That's as true a reason as any, why they use senseless vague ultimately meaningless generalizations to describe any Congressperson's voting record, rather than actually cite specific votes... because if they cite the votes, then they risk getting a substantial discussion going:
"so he voted that particular way on that particular legislation? gee, what's so bad about that?"
You better believe that's the last thing this "media" wants: a substantial discussion of any political issue at all, with details and specifics included.
Better to just play on voter's vague impressions and prejudices... better to keep away from details and specifics, and instead use meaningless generalizations in discussing political issues.
That right there pretty much describes the complete context in which we presently hear the word "liberal" used by the worthless "media"
Posted Friday June 6, 2008 4:53:43 PM EDT / Flag this comment
Posted by Science101 in reply to juliajayne
provide more children with health insurance
SCHIP in its form presented for vote, was not what majority of Americans wanted. Sorry to burst your bubble.
Posted Friday June 6, 2008 6:11:55 PM EDT / Flag this comment
Posted by eweston8542983 in reply to Science101
Posted Friday June 6, 2008 7:23:57 PM EDT / Flag this comment
Posted by jeter2
Summary: USA Today uncritically reported that Sen. John McCain "noted" that Sen. Barack Obama "was once named the most liberal senator by National Journal magazine." But USA Today did not report that McCain himself "did not vote frequently enough" to receive a rating.
Aw come on...McCain would be rated the Most Maverick Senator of course!
Not showing up to vote makes him a rebel ;-)
Posted Friday June 6, 2008 4:38:20 PM EDT / Flag this comment
Posted by juliajayne in reply to jeter2
Posted Friday June 6, 2008 4:39:29 PM EDT / Flag this comment
Posted by jeter2 in reply to juliajayne
Posted Friday June 6, 2008 4:41:40 PM EDT / Flag this comment
Posted by snoopy in reply to jeter2
Posted Friday June 6, 2008 4:45:05 PM EDT / Flag this comment
Posted by juliajayne in reply to snoopy
Posted Friday June 6, 2008 4:50:07 PM EDT / Flag this comment
Posted by wzwriter in reply to jeter2
Aw come on...McCain would be rated the Most Maverick Senator of course!
Not showing up to vote makes him a rebel ;-)
We've already established that Gramps McCain is a Ford Maverick:
NOW are you saying he's an AMC Rebel??? :-)
Posted Friday June 6, 2008 4:58:44 PM EDT / Flag this comment
Posted by Col. Harlan Sanders in reply to wzwriter
I'm thinking this is the most appropriate ride for Grampy in a few months.
Posted Friday June 6, 2008 5:34:35 PM EDT / Flag this comment
Posted by captfoster2
I think its aweful funny that the corporate owned media thinks that by bringing up Obama's voting record as somehow the most liberal.... as if that's a bad thing.... will somehow stop people from voting for him!
Besides..... Bernie Sanders is the most liberal, by far!
Also, wasn't John Kerry the most liberal senator back in 2004?
Come to think of it.... wasn't Al Gore the most liberal politician in 2000?
Can;t the right-wing get their story straight?
Posted Friday June 6, 2008 4:39:51 PM EDT / Flag this comment
Posted by wookie in reply to captfoster2
Posted Friday June 6, 2008 4:43:58 PM EDT / Flag this comment
Posted by SFnomad in reply to wookie
I heard somewhere else Obama was a Muslim Marxist. How can he keep all these hats straight?
As to him being the "most liberal" ... I'm sure the National Journal cherry picked the votes they used to come up with the conclusion they were looking for. They fixed the facts around results they wanted. The NJ would be most useful birdcage liner.
Posted Friday June 6, 2008 5:24:17 PM EDT / Flag this comment
Posted by snoopy
Posted Friday June 6, 2008 4:42:07 PM EDT / Flag this comment
Posted by anotheramerican in reply to snoopy
Posted Friday June 6, 2008 4:55:15 PM EDT / Flag this comment
Posted by wzwriter in reply to anotheramerican
I don't know of any conservative that 'hates' Obama.
Try listening to Mark Levin's radio pukefest for more than five minutes.
Posted Friday June 6, 2008 5:00:17 PM EDT / Flag this comment
Posted by MoonbatYouBet in reply to anotheramerican
Posted Friday June 6, 2008 5:00:37 PM EDT / Flag this comment
Posted by juliajayne in reply to MoonbatYouBet
Good question, AA. Do you hear yourself?
Can we have one reality check, a side of sanity and a glass of reason.
Posted Friday June 6, 2008 5:11:19 PM EDT / Flag this comment
Posted by dbeden4153 in reply to anotheramerican
You should meet my uncle.
He said "I ain't voting for no n****r who changes their name to Obama. Obama is not an American name."
He truly hates him (he's also from WV. Nothing against WV, but I think that's worth noting.)
Posted Friday June 6, 2008 5:11:43 PM EDT / Flag this comment
Posted by wookie in reply to dbeden4153
Posted Friday June 6, 2008 5:17:48 PM EDT / Flag this comment
Posted by laughinglefty
Posted Friday June 6, 2008 11:25:30 PM EDT / Flag this comment
Posted by pieter b
Posted Monday June 9, 2008 12:05:48 PM EDT / Flag this comment